UK tribunal rejects government bid to keep its Apple iCloud backdoor order secret

19.11.2026 4 min 13

On 19 November the Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the UK government's bid to keep secret its order demanding that Apple build access to encrypted iCloud data. The Home Office had argued that even admitting the order exists would harm national security. The tribunal disagreed: the government "has not established that it would be damaging to national security to reveal" the order, and in its judgment the tribunal itself states that the Home Office served Apple a technical capability notice, Reuters reported.

The ruling decides only what can be said in public. Whether the order is lawful will be argued at a full hearing in the first half of 2027, and what the notice actually demands from Apple stays secret for now.

Why the secrecy argument failed

Under the Investigatory Powers Act, a company that receives a technical capability notice may not disclose it, and the government's standard line is to "neither confirm nor deny". At a hearing on 17 September, Apple, Privacy International and Liberty argued that this position had become an affront to open justice. The government's lawyer replied that dropping it would "provide material assistance to hostile actors".

The tribunal found the Home Office's national security assessment "flawed in the public law sense", City AM reported. The existence of the order has been widely reported for almost two years, and the judges pointed to what they called "authorised leaks" to The Times and the Financial Times that confirmed it. Home Office witnesses said leak inquiries had found no government source. The tribunal noted that the department provided no investigation reports, no details of the steps taken and no statements from ministers denying they had authorised the briefings.

The judgment also records that the UK allowed Apple to brief the US Vice President and Attorney General about the order but not Congress. That restriction was the subject of a letter from two US lawmakers to the tribunal in September. Alongside the public ruling, the tribunal issued private judgments that cannot be published.

Two notices and Apple's disabled iCloud protection

The first notice, served in January 2025, covered encrypted iCloud backups of both British and American users. It was dropped after negotiations with the Trump administration and replaced by a notice that applies only to Apple's UK customers. In August 2026 Apple filed a new complaint against that second notice.

The practical effect for users has not changed since February 2025, when Apple withdrew Advanced Data Protection in Britain rather than build a way in. The feature extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups, photos and notes, so that Apple holds no keys. People in the UK still cannot turn it on, and outside the UK it is available as before. Apple has said it has "never built a backdoor or master key" to any of its products and never will, 9to5Mac noted.

What happens next

  • Full hearing in 2027: the tribunal will decide whether the notice is lawful, with much of the hearing now held in open court.
  • A parallel case: the complaint by Privacy International and Liberty will be heard alongside Apple's.
  • The content stays closed: how far the technical details of the order can be disclosed will be decided separately later.
  • No comment yet: the government told Reuters it could not comment because of its "neither confirm nor deny" policy, and Apple did not respond immediately.

ukappleicloudbackdoorencryptione2eeprivacysurveillancecourtinvestigatory powers actadvanced data protection

Read also